Home > food, Italian, pasta > Seriously, Best Lasagna Ever (thank you Smitten Kitchen!)

Seriously, Best Lasagna Ever (thank you Smitten Kitchen!)

Holy crap this is good. Ps you can't see my salad

You have to make this! I don’t normally eat a lot of lasagna: I never order it at restaurants and we have it at home rarely. However, Smitten Kitchen posted a recipe and hailed it as her culinary Mount Everest, which piqued my interest. Soon after, Tuna Toast called it The Best Lasagna Ever. Boy, were they right!! Something that’s often a dense gut bomb was transformed into a light but comforting meal that had me looking forward to dinner several nights this week. Call me Garfield.

It takes some time to put together, but the methods aren’t difficult. The bolognese I knew I could handle. However, pasta was new for me. I got a KitchenAid pasta attachment for Christmas last year and had yet to use it. I’d previously attempted bechamel twice for moussaka and failed both times. Deb’s directions seemed straightforward so I went for it. We hibernated last weekend after consecutive weekends out of town, so I had the time to enjoy the process.

On Saturday, I made the bolognese, which is a simple meat sauce. I added an extra carrot because I like carrots and only had 1.75 cups of wine (I gave up wine for Lent so that’s all that was left in the previously opened bottle). Otherwise, I stuck to the recipe.


Best Lasagna Ever

On Sunday morning, I made the dough for the pasta. My friend Tom said he can get homemade pasta ready before a pot of water boils, so once I get the hang of things, it shouldn’t be too difficult. Me and flour get pretty messy though.

I didn’t let the dough rest as Deb recommended because I had to get to yoga. It was fine. I did make sure to send the dough through the pasta maker a bunch of times to build up the elasticity (something I learned in a bread baking class). On the widest setting, I would send the dough through, fold it into thirds, and send it through again. I repeated this step a bunch of times until I felt the dough had good elasticity. Is this necessary? I don’t know, but my pasta tasted like pasta!

I left the rolled out pasta on wax paper and left for yoga.

Best Lasagna Ever

Best Lasagna Ever

Making pasta for tonight's lasagna

When I got back, I cut the pasta into squares, boiled and shocked them per the recipe. The pasta had dried out a bit but that didn’t matter.

Best Lasagna Ever

Best Lasagna Ever

Again, followed the recipe almost exactly for the bechamel and it turned out great. The trick is to be patient and trust that the bechamel will turn out. In my previous failures, I panicked early on and added extra milk or flour which ruined the consistency in the end. This bechamel worked perfectly and I’ll just use this for all bechamels moving forward.

I made my layers a little meatier than Deb, but I had enough ingredients (I didn’t set any sauce aside as Deb recommended) for a large lasagna pan and a smaller 4.5×5.5 that went straight into the freezer. I could have easily made additional layers on the one pan but I knew I wanted freeze some for later. (UPDATE: I just ate the batch I froze and it was as delicious as the day I made it! Just thaw in the fridge the day before and bake as directed.)

Next time I am doubling this because it is so delicious and totally worth the effort!

Best Lasagna Ever

Best Lasagna Ever

Best Lasagna Ever

Best Lasagna Ever


Whiskey–all I’m drinking until Easter.

Categories: food, Italian, pasta Tags:
  1. Brian
    March 2, 2012 at 2:54 pm

    Thanks, will definitely have to try that!

  2. Kathy
    March 5, 2012 at 12:43 pm

    I’m so impressed you made it! I ooed and aaahed when I first read the post on Smitten Kitchen and then when I read yours. I don’t know about you, but I plan on buying her cookbook. I hope her writing style comes through in it.

  3. Lan
    March 5, 2012 at 7:05 pm

    Kathy it was totally worth it! Take a stab when you have a lazy weekend. I try not to buy cookbooks due to my constant moving but you could easily sway me 🙂

  1. September 6, 2013 at 3:18 pm
  2. January 15, 2014 at 1:59 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: